Get the Monday Brief
Strategy · Interview

Coyuchi's early UGC sold cute sheets. Shoppers bounced at the $678 price

Its president says the UGC now explains what organic cotton does for you. Coyuchi also hands free products to affiliates that AI chatbots cite.

By The EditorPublished November 17, 2026Interview of September 1, 2026
Vicky Williams Grahan, Coyuchi on Shopify Masters▶

Vicky Williams Grahan of Coyuchi on Shopify Masters. Press play to start at the key moment.

Vicky Williams Grahanpresident, Coyuchi

Coyuchi has sold organic sheets and towels since 1991, at premium prices. Its president, Vicky Williams Grahan, told Shopify Masters, in an episode posted Sept. 1, how the brand's first round of UGC ads went wrong.

Cute got the click, not the sale

…there was a lot of UGC that was in our meta campaigns, right? And we still have a lot of UGC and it's working very well for us. But that's because we've taken a different approach to the UGC.
Vicky Williams Grahan at 12:19
Get the Monday Brief in your inbox

The early videos sold looks.

But the initial UGC was around like look how cute these sheets are. And it got amazing click-through rates because the sheets were cute.
Vicky Williams Grahan at 12:29
But then someone got to the website and it was pure sticker shock. Like, wait, what? These sheets that you just told me were so cute cost $678.
Vicky Williams Grahan at 12:36

Shoppers left at once. Now the brand is upfront about the premium and gives people reasons to pay it. The UGC now covers waking up rested, not breathing in microplastics in bed, skin that is not soaking up chemicals, and cotton that gets softer with every wash instead of feeling like sandpaper after 10 washes. Customer testimonials help too: buyers say that they have had the same sheets or towels for 10 years.

…that's the storytelling that we have to do in UGC and elsewhere to really help people understand.
Vicky Williams Grahan at 13:45

Free products for the pages AI quotes

Coyuchi's "how did you hear about us" survey shows AI chatbots are its fastest-growing source of new customers. Years of press calling its organic textiles the best gave it a head start, and its PR and affiliate team now flags which outlets asking for product are the ones chatbots cite most.

…especially if it's something like you they want a free $4,000 mattress. It's like, okay, should we do that? If it's highly cited by an LLM, we'll go ahead and we'll do it. I literally approved one this morning.
Vicky Williams Grahan at 15:23

One famous face per age group

The brand also signed celebrity collaborations because few people knew it. She called Coyuchi an "if you know, you know" brand. Its biggest customer groups are Gen X and boomers, while 18 to 25 year olds are growing fastest. Naomi Watts fronted a campaign aimed at Gen X. Rocky Barnes came next, picked to stand for the young, modern mom. Williams Grahan called the collaborations "majorly successful."

Get the next one in your inbox

Free. Pick what you want, leave any time.

Source: How I Scaled a Legacy Brand into an Organic Lifestyle Empire, Shopify Masters. Every quote is word for word from the recording and checked against it by script before publishing. How we report.

More interviews

With Keena Grigsby, William Hicks, Kim-lin Capes and morePlaybook
Strategy

How to work with micro influencers: what Samsung, L'Oréal and Magic Mind do

With Keena Grigsby, William Hicks, Kim-lin Capes and more
November 17, 2026
Keena Grigsby, Samsung Electronics AmericaInterview
Strategy

Samsung's mobile CMO meets its creator team before a phone launches

Keena Grigsby, Samsung Electronics America
November 17, 2026
Nicholas Wedewer, Hims & HersInterview
Strategy

Hims & Hers makes creators say whether they took the treatment

Nicholas Wedewer, Hims & Hers
November 17, 2026

News from the experts, delivered to your inbox.

What founders and brand leads said on camera, word for word. Pick the lists you want. All newsletters

Get it in your inbox

The Monday Brief, free in your inbox